Have a tendency to when dates are provided, he is provided that have a day of week you to definitely really does maybe not match with this go out whilst into the real background. One particular analogy takes place in Harry Potter while the Prisoner away from Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney refers to 16 Oct because Monday, even though sixteen Oct 1993 are a friday.

There are also contradictions from inside the courses in this field. Such, during the Harry Potter while the Cup out-of Fire, each other step 1 September and you may 2 September are provided because Mondays and you can, for the Harry Potter while the Prisoner of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s trial is set to your 20 April, however, mindful parsing of the text message shows that this may has took place zero after than just March.

Together with, inside Harry Potter and also the Cup regarding Flames they say that the Champions was indeed selected towards Monday 30 October, but 30 October is a friday within the 1994.

Within the a bankruptcy proceeding off Quidditch From Ages, they state the first Quidditch Industry Glass happened into the 1473. Should your title is held every number of years, this disputes toward declaration within the Cup out of Flame your 1994 Industry Mug try the brand new 422nd. If Quidditch From the Decades is great, the newest 422nd Quidditch Community Mug do in reality fall-in the year 3161, but if Goblet of Flames is useful, the first World Mug was held inside 306.

Historical difficulties [ ]

Whilst the show, depending on the schedule based on the Chamber regarding Secrets resource, is decided on the 1990s, the series commonly appears as if it is set in the new later nineties so you’re able to mid-2000s, about concurrent towards the book of the guides. Inside Harry Potter and Half-Bloodstream Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a male pronoun to refer on the “predecessor” of your own Best Minister of your British. According to the significantly more than schedule, this will take place in the summertime of 1996, in the event the Prime Minister are John Major, whose instantaneous predecessor is actually a woman (is the reason earliest ending up in Fudge, the ebook states the fresh election, but Major was not first picked and just got over shortly after Thatcher resigned.

You are able, but not unlikely, one to Fudge might possibly be writing about a far more distant predecessor, since the Thatcher grabbed place of work before Fudge allegedly became Minister for Miracle. (Even though one can think a scenario where Fudge are delegated because of the Minister to have Secret in order to satisfy towards the Best Minister as he, Fudge, was at a smaller sized workplace.) Simultaneously, this new identification and reputation of the top Minister represented seems to much more directly meets compared to Tony Blair than just off John Major. A blog post regarding Every day Post cards one Rowling try close to your up coming-Chancellor of one’s white men date cuban women Exchequer Gordon Brown (tend to viewed as a competition in order to Blair’s management of your Labor Team, who been successful him and you may turned Primary Minister), hence she might have been attempting to show Blair’s terrible front side. If for example the instructions had been devote connect which have guide go out of Philosopher’s Brick, after that it enjoy do take place in 2002 (shortly after Blair turned Perfect Minister).

Although not, it had been after reported that 22 November was a friday, it was at 1994

The same problem involves Nicolas Flamel, who was simply stated as actually 665 during the very first book, however, Nicolas Flamel are a bona fide historical contour and you may won’t have reached you to definitely years up to 1996, within the date the first book try penned. Brand new rebuttal for this is the fact that the day the brand new “real” Nicolas Flamel came to be will not communicate with new Nicolas Flamel away from Harry Potter.

Another type of situation can be acquired regarding Rubeus Hagrid’s tenure as the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s meant on series that Hagrid was given one status contained in this many years away from his expulsion of school inside the 1942. However in you to scene off Harry Potter plus the Cup out of Fire, Molly Weasley reminisces in the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper apparently overlap that have Molly’s many years at school, it appears unlikely you to definitely she remembers a previous gamekeeper. However, you are able you to definitely Hagrid did not getting a good gamekeeper quickly once becoming expelled, but instead been because the Ogg’s assistant. That is plausible as when Harry thinks that he will end up being expelled to possess traveling towards broomstick in place of permission within his first year, the guy miracle if the he would be allowed to remain on just like the Hagrid’s secretary.